The Ceiling Is Coming Off
For years, employers have had a rough sense of their worst case in an unfair dismissal claim. The compensatory award has been capped at the lower of a year's gross pay or a fixed statutory limit. That cap shaped how businesses weighed risk, how they priced settlements and, if we are honest, how carefully some of them followed process.
That changes on 1 January 2027. Under the Employment Rights Act 2025, the government's published timeline confirms two linked changes for dismissals from that date:
- the qualifying period for ordinary unfair dismissal protection drops from two years to six months
- the cap on the compensatory award is removed
Either change alone would matter. Together, they reshape the risk of every dismissal decision you make. As with all the Act's timings, the government notes that dates remain subject to parliamentary process and may change, so keep an eye on official updates.
What "Uncapped" Actually Means
An unfair dismissal award is usually made up of two parts.
The basic award is a formula based on age, length of service and weekly pay (itself subject to a weekly cap). This is not the part that is changing.
The compensatory award is meant to put the employee back in the position they would have been in, as far as possible, had they not been unfairly dismissed. It covers things like lost earnings up to the hearing, future loss of earnings, and loss of pension and other benefits.
Today, that compensatory element hits a ceiling. From 1 January 2027 it will not. A tribunal will be able to award whatever it considers just and equitable for the loss actually suffered.
For a junior employee who finds new work quickly, that may make little difference. For a senior manager on a strong package, in a niche role, who takes a year or more to find comparable work, the numbers can grow very quickly.
Why This Matters More Than It First Appears
Your highest earners become your biggest exposure
The old cap had the biggest limiting effect on well-paid staff. Removing it means the employees whose dismissals carry the most commercial weight, such as directors, senior managers and specialists, now carry the most financial risk too.
Settlement conversations change
Many settlement agreements have been negotiated in the shadow of the cap. Employees and their advisers knew the ceiling, and so did you. Without it, expect higher opening positions from senior leavers, and expect them to be backed by a credible argument about what a tribunal could award.
Six months plus uncapped is a new combination
From January, someone with as little as six months' service will be able to bring an ordinary unfair dismissal claim. Pair that with an uncapped award and a rushed decision about a recent senior hire stops being a low-risk shortcut.
Process Is Now Your Main Protection
None of this means you cannot dismiss. Employers can still fairly dismiss for capability, conduct, redundancy and other recognised reasons. What it means is that how you dismiss carries far more weight.
The businesses that will be most exposed are those that:
- rely on informal conversations instead of documented performance management
- treat probation as a formality and make decisions at the last minute
- run redundancy processes without genuine consultation or proper selection criteria
- let managers handle dismissals without guidance or sign-off
Tribunals look at whether you had a fair reason, followed a fair procedure and acted reasonably. With the cap gone, gaps in any of those areas cost more.
What to Do Before 1 January 2027
1. Identify your high-exposure roles
List the roles where a dismissal would carry the largest potential loss: senior, well-paid, specialist or hard-to-replace positions. These are where process discipline matters most.
2. Tighten performance management now
If you have concerns about someone's performance or conduct, start documenting fairly and consistently now. Clear objectives, regular reviews, written records and reasonable support give you a defensible position later.
3. Rethink probation
With protection arriving at six months, probation reviews need to be structured and completed on time, with clear outcomes. Waiting until month seven to raise concerns is no longer a safe option.
4. Train the managers who make the decisions
Most unfair dismissal claims start with a manager who meant well but skipped a step. Make sure line managers understand what a fair process looks like and when they need HR involved.
5. Review your settlement approach
If you use settlement agreements, revisit how you assess and price them. The assumptions you used last year may not hold for dismissals from 2027.
6. Check your insurance
If you hold employment practices liability cover, check how it responds to uncapped awards and whether your limits still make sense.
The Bigger Picture
The Employment Rights Act 2025 is shifting the balance towards early, fair and well-documented people management. Uncapped compensation is one of the clearest examples. It does not punish employers who already manage well. It raises the cost of getting it wrong.
The good news is that the fix is within your control. Clear processes, confident managers and good records reduce your risk far more than any cap ever did.
How Insightful Group Can Help
If you would like a second pair of eyes on your dismissal, probation or performance processes before January, Insightful Group can help you review where your exposure sits and what to tighten first. This article is general guidance rather than legal advice, so for specific cases, speak to an HR or employment law professional.
