Leadership’s Most Dangerous Assumption? That You Must Always Know.
For many CEOs, the pressure isn’t loud — it’s quiet.
It lives in the pauses between decisions. In the meetings where all eyes turn to you.
In the moments when you don’t know, but feel like you can’t admit it.
You’re the final stop. The one expected to provide clarity, direction, and certainty — even when the path forward is foggy.
But what if always having the answer isn’t the job?
The Mask of Certainty
In many boardrooms, confidence is currency. And so, leaders often perform certainty — even when wrestling with real doubt.
But that mask comes at a cost:
- It creates distance
- It limits collaboration
- It leads to isolated, risk-averse decision-making
What the Data Tells Us
According to a 2023 report by the Chartered Management Institute, nearly 70% of UK managers admit they struggle to make decisions when they feel unsupported.
If that’s the reality for managers — imagine the pressure at the very top.
3 Signs You’re Carrying the Load Alone
Decision delays and avoidance — because the stakes feel too high
Lack of challenge from your team — because you’ve accidentally shut down dialogue
Resentment building quietly — in yourself or others, due to unshared burden
The Myth of the All-Knowing CEO
Modern leadership isn’t about having all the answers. It’s about creating the conditions for the right answers to emerge.
That looks like:
- Asking better questions
- Modelling vulnerability and curiosity
- Creating psychological safety in your leadership team
- Letting go of ego, and leaning into exploration
How to Relieve the Pressure
You don’t need to shoulder everything alone.
🔹 Rebuild a challenge-friendly team culture 🔹 Create structured spaces for complex thinking 🔹 Engage a trusted external sounding board — someone who isn’t tangled in your org chart or office politics
When you’re free to think aloud, test your logic, and say “I’m not sure yet” — your clarity and confidence improve.
Final Thoughts: You’re Not Failing — You’re Human
You’re not weak for not knowing. You’re not failing for feeling the weight.
You’re a human being in an extraordinary role.
The pressure to always know is real — but it’s also optional.
You can choose a leadership model that values: ✨ Thinking aloud ✨ Collaborating wisely ✨ Building strategic resilience
Need a Trusted Thinking Partner?
At Insightful Group, we provide CEOs and senior leaders with confidential, judgment-free space to reflect, strategise, and lead with confidence.
Email us or start with our free HR Audit.
Feeling the weight of always needing to have the answers? Our Fractional HR Directors provide confidential, strategic support to help CEOs create space for better decision-making and collaborative leadership. Book a strategy call to discuss how we can support your leadership journey.
Ready to Transform Your HR Strategy?
Get expert guidance from our Fractional HR Directors to solve your people challenges and drive business growth.